352 pages
4 Stars
I think the title is somewhat misleading, it wasn't just
good old Genghis who changed the world, but his sons and grandsons. And change it
they did, without a doubt. Did they change it as much as stated in this book? I
don't know. I also don't know enough to put forth an intelligent argument for
or against.
What I do think is this should have been written as two
books, Volume I on Genghis (who dies fairly early in this book) and Volume II
on the rest of the crowd. I have read a few books on Genghis, and while this
book does bring to light some heretofore-unknown tidbits, it doesn't tell
nearly as much as I'd hoped, especially from Weatherford. I've also read a
couple of books about Kublai, and again, this book seemed to gloss over some
fascinating areas. Two books, each in the 400-500 page range would have been a
treat most rare.
I won't get into the "who invented noodles first"
– Mongols or Europeans argument? From what I've read just about all
agricultural communities that grew wheat or a similar grain, came up with a
form of noodles. And also, from what I've read, the Mongols had a real
antipathy toward blood and raw meat, and I can't help but wonder about them
placing meat between them and their horses to tenderize it. Between the horse
and the saddle would seem to be a. unbalancing, and b. too iffy to rub sores on
the horse. I believe they did put milk in bags tied to their saddles to beat it
into butter or yogurt, or at least fermenting it. I can picture them doing the
same with the meat to tenderize it, but cooking it later.
I absolutely loved the parts where Weatherford talked about
having been there, seeing the places, being with the locals who explained
various things to him, such as why horses would go in this direction, how to
tell if the ice is thick enough to ride across, etc. I also appreciated the
maps. Really appreciated the maps!
All in all, if you're interested in Genghis Khan, read this
book. But don't stop when you put the book down. Try some of John Man's books;
he, too, has been there. This book is easily read, it is not a textbook, it is
very accessible to the average person, and the history buff will, I'm sure,
enjoy it. I did. There are several excellent books out there about Genghis, and
this is a good one.
No comments:
Post a Comment